What is the target for the US boots ?
Seizing Kharg or Hormuz Island ??
Either one can be subject to Iranian Drone attack ..
Marines vs Iran : What a Real Conflict Would Actually Look Like
Ryan McBeth
AI Summary :
This video analyzes what a potential military conflict between US Marines and Iran would look like, specifically focusing on the capabilities of a Marine Expeditionary Unit (MEU) and the logistics of securing specific locations in the Persian Gulf (0:00-0:32).
What is a MEU? (0:32-4:44)
Ryan explains that a MEU is not just a combat force, but a versatile "fist" combining four essential elements:
Command Element: Provides command, control, intelligence, and electronic warfare (1:37).
Ground Combat Element: An infantry battalion augmented with artillery, amphibious vehicles, combat engineers, and anti-armor capabilities (1:50).
Aviation Combat Element: Utilizes MV-22 Ospreys for troop transport, F-35B Lightning IIs for air superiority and ground attack, and AH-1Z Vipers for close air support (2:16).
Logistics Combat Element: Handles supply, maintenance, transportation, and medical services (2:45).
The video highlights that when reports say "5,000 Marines," it actually translates to roughly 1,200 combat trigger-pullers supported by a much larger logistical and aviation force (3:09).
Mission Scenarios (4:49-10:50)
Ryan breaks down possible scenarios for the USS Tripoli and its Amphibious Ready Group:
Lebanon Support: Unlikely, as other forces are closer (4:53).
Securing the Strait of Hormuz Coastline: Dangerous and impractical for a small force (5:30).
Taking Kharg Island: This would shut down 90% of Iran's oil exports (6:16). However, this creates a major humanitarian issue, forcing the US to manage the island's population while under drone attack (7:11).
Seizing Hormuz Island: Ryan suggests this as a more likely scenario. Based on a historical Portuguese strategy, controlling this island could allow the US to control the Strait of Hormuz, establish a forward base, and potentially train Iranian rebels to push towards Bandar Abbas (8:45).